— The Tribunal Procedure Committee is consulting on a proposal by HESC Chamber President Mark Sutherland Williams to remove Tribunal rule 34, thereby abolishing pre-hearing medical examinations, and in consequence to remove rule 39(2)(b). (1) The Chamber President’s rationale is: (a) the reason for PHEs, to compensate for poor or inexperienced medical evidence, is less compelling than it was in 1959; (b) the Mental Health Act 2025 will increase pressure and consultant psychiatrists are a limited resource; (c) there were fewer PHEs during coronavirus with no change in discharge rates; (d) the unilateral fact-gathering exercise creates asymmetry between the panel and the parties, and gives rise to questions of fairness and balance; (e) late notice requests create listing difficulties; and (f) there are physical safety and data confidentiality concerns on behalf of medical members. (2) The TPC’s provisional conclusion is that speaking to one party in the absence of the other may not be appropriate in a modern judicial system, so rule 34 should be removed; however, its alternative proposal is to retain PHEs for when the tribunal directs one.
Full details available at: https://www.mentalhealthlaw.co.uk/TPC,_%27Possible_amendments_to_the_Tribunal_Procedure_(FTT)_(HESC)_Rules_2008:_Medical_examinations%27_(consultation_from_12_November_2026_to_4_February_2027)?id=121126-2228